Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Technically: not a clue.

Modern keys are complex things. Gone are the days where you can have a piece of metal re-cut for $5 at Home Depot. A replacement key for modern cars is an expensive proposition: they have to be custom-ordered from the factory (with proof of identity and insurance) then programmed by your dealer. Replacement keys for modern Audis/BMWs/Mercedes run $300-400 all-in. (Remember that scene from Gone in 60 Seconds? And that was 15 years ago. And also a movie.)

You can buy blanks, sure, but without programming, it's nothing more than a hunk of metal.

Is it somehow possible to "clone" a key? Never underestimate hackers, but it ain't easy. Per Brian-Puccio's use-case, unless the previous owner is presenting auto exploits at DefCon, you don't have to worry about someone having a copy of a key you don't know about. (And if they've lost it, you can go to the dealer and have it un-registered.)

Aside: Google around for articles on new car theft: you'll find that no thieves are copying keys or hot wiring or anything like that. In fact, the "new thing" is to get a signal amplifier that allows a car's keyless entry/start system to "find" a key that's sitting 100 feet away inside someone's house or office, then just drive away.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: