Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | sinca's commentslogin

Is there a tl'dr?

I think we can name the science part of computer science "algorithmic science" (or something to the same effect) and the engineering part "computer engineering" and call it a day.


The reasons for not calling Computer Science a science vary mostly based on the background of the beholder. Some object because "we only compute man-made objects", while others argue that "Computer Science is not a science, and has little to do with computers."

A graphic in the article lists these areas and problems:

  Area & Problem
  
  Computation
  • Unbounded error accumulation on finite machines
  • Non-computability of some important problems
  • Intractability of thousands of common problems
  • Optimal algorithms for some common problems
  • Production quality compilers
  
  Communication
  • Lossless file compression
  • Lossy but high-fidelity audio and video compression
  • Error correction codes for high, bursty noise channels
  • Secure cryptographic key exchange in open networks
  
  Interaction
  • Arbitration problem
  • Timing-dependent (race-conditioned) bug problem
  • Deadlock problem
  • Fast algorithms for predicting throughput and response time
  • Internet protocols
  • Cryptographic authentication protocols
  
  Recollection
  • Locality
  • Thrashing
  • Search
  • Two-level mapping for access to shared objects
  
  Automation
  • Simulations of focused cognitive tasks
  • Limits on expert systems
  • Reverse Turing tests
  
  Design
  • Objects and information hiding
  • Levels
  • Throughput and response time prediction networks of servers


Exactly my thoughts. Reading all the quotes on Gawker, I fail to see how they arrived at the conclusion that PG's implying that one needs to be male in order to be a good programer.

I see a few points being made ("out of context"): - You want to start programming at 13 to be a hacker. - 13 year old girls are not interested in programming. - PG doesn't know how to make programming more attractive to this group.

As far as I can tell these are neutral observations and opinions. Even if his statement is plainly incorrect, simply being wrong doesn't make it offensive.


Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: