Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | shuntress's commentslogin

Phone screens dont need to be user-swappable but apple should be forced to sell each module (screen, frame, camera board, main board, etc).


Please be careful not to argue to "force" a company to do something they already do...

https://support.apple.com/self-service-repair


First of all, they only do that because they are already forced.

Second of all, have you actually looked at the process? It is very obviously onerous in ways that could be avoided.


Awesome that you can finally buy some parts (Apple was years late in this compared to competitors).

Have you seen how insane the rental tool kit is?

https://selfservicerepair.com/en-US/tool-kit-rental

Here’s a video showing how the battery replacement process works:

https://youtu.be/3P1kEy--d9E

Heres the part list for the iPhone 17 Pro tool kit:

Case 1

661-17619 - Heated Display Removal Fixture

661-52832 - Heated Display Pocket

Case 2

923-02657 - Battery Press

661-08916 - Display Press

923-01092 - Adhesive Cutter

922-5065 - Nylon Probe (Black Stick)

923-0248 - Black Torque Driver Kit

923-00738 - Gray Torque Driver

923-00105 - Green Torque Driver

923-0448 - Blue Torque Driver

923-01290 - Micro Stix® Bit

923-02066 - Super screw Bit

923-02995 - Adjustable torque driver (10-34 Ncm)

923-09176 - Adhesive Removal Tool

923-09177 - JCIS Bit for Adjustable Torque Driver

923-09962 - Superscrew Bit for Adjustable Torque Driver

923-08085 - Teal Torque Driver

923-08131 - Orange Torque Driver

923-07594 - Torx Plus 4IP 25mm bit

923-09721 - Housing Protective Cover

923-10961 - Display Protective Cover

923-12855 - Repair Tray

923-13313 - Back Protective Cover Magnetizer

ESD-safe tweezers

Case 3

923-13470 - Logic Board Dock

923-12856 - Logic Board Dock Insert (mmWave)

923-13465 - Logic Board Dock Insert (non-mmWave)

This is not “self service,” this is service that requires professional level tools and skills masquerading as self-service to satisfy regulators.

I think that Apple wants it to be this complicated so they can tell regulators “See? We complied but it’s totally insane, we told you users can’t possibly repair their own equipment!”

Apple also has a long history of making repair difficult for third party repair companies.

Meanwhile, the battery replacement process for the Fairphone only requires one tool:

https://support.fairphone.com/hc/en-us/articles/245900296211...


Just the battery would be a great start.

For a laptop, nearly everything should be modular.


Regarding point #2, while it is of course entirely possible that they are slackers it is more likely that they lack the knowledge you are leveraging in order to declare that the PRs are "simple"


This is basically the thing I keep coming back to with the agentic tools. It is the wrangling requirements, stamping out confusion, and steering away from a trainwreck down the line that are the actual challenging parts of the job and we can't automate those yet. Once you do actually know the code change you want to make though it is pretty nice to change it 10x faster than before.


Truly democratizing the web requires that "Compute Server" becomes a typical home appliance that is no more difficult to use than an oven or a furnace including the widespread access to vocational technicians who come to your house and fix it for you.


This guy is not totally wrong but he is also way off about pretty much everything even just simple basic facts. He writes "Michigan Stadium, the third‑largest sports venue on earth." which is not even remotely true. Michican Stadium isn't even in the top 5 of venues in the US never mind globally[0]. And thats if you just take capacity counts at face value and don't try to include places that have huge standing room capacity like horse racing tracks.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sports_venues_by_capac...


You’re technically correct, but

I ran through the list, Michigan Dome is the third largest sports venue on earth, for team sports, or better yet, the third largest sports venue that everyone in attendance can witness all of the events taking place.

Like the author of the piece we are discussing, I don’t consider auto or horse race tracks to be a singular, contiguous sports venue’, obviously you can fit a ton of people alongside a track that is multiple miles long, the seating areas aren’t always continuous, etc.

The stadiums in India and North Korea are similar to Michigan Dome, all spectators can see the same event occur the entire time it is occuring, auto racing doesn’t really allow this, not sure about horse racing.


Yeah. The NYC Marathon would seem to be the largest venue in America. No wait, that's nonsense.


I am convinced that there is an absurd amount of unrealized potential for spectating in eSports. But everyone seems to just deliver an experience that is more-or-less "like playing the game yourself, but worse, and with forced-hype commentary" rather than an actually engaging spectator product.


Ah yes, of course, The Beautiful Game is clearly not at all about the actual game...


Baseball is killer in-person but it's also pretty nice to just have on TV. There is nothing else like the tension of a critical at-bat.

Football is actually really really weird for a spectator sport and, I think, is generally presented very poorly. 80% of the game is deciphering opposing formations to determine what they each are predicting the opposing formation is about to try to do.


Football is just a really complicated sport; one reason I think it’s popular is that it’s fun on a visceral physical individual level (“Wow, look at that run/block/hit/kick”) for ‘beginners’ watching and is also intellectually engaging as you learn more, “wait, how did they shift the secondary just now??”

Baseball - I like it in lots of forms, too. But I think a good radio announcer can get you most of the fun out of a critical at bat narrating.


I recently watched Brockmire with Hank Azaria, and thought it was funny how the actual game announcing were just mere interruptions to whatever else he was talking about at the time. Which is pretty much how I find watching sports at a bar when there's multiple screens with multiple games and people you're with not actually into any of it.


Football is so unique in that the way it’s presented makes it almost impossible to understand what’s going on. There are a million rules, which even die-hard fans don’t understand. And the broadcast doesn’t even make an attempt to explain or even show the offensive or defensive formations and plays being chosen.

It feels like what we’re shown on tv is a very narrow slice of what’s going on. We see the ball moving down the field but have no idea what the coach or quarterback is doing. Somehow it’s still an incredible watch though.


The plays belong to the individual teams, which is, I heard, why they don't broadcast full field views.

No idea if it's true or not


There are some recent experiments with consumer-facing full field: (Prime Vision All-22). They were held closely for a long time, though.


I went to a ball game to watch a buddy's kid throw a first pitch. I didn't know that there was more than one first pitch. We sat around talking after their first pitch and it was already the 3rd inning before I realized the game had actually started. I must have missed the "play ball" announcement.


Every MLB game I've ever been to has had that happen lol. 3 'first pitches' and then the actual start of the game happens with absolutely zero fanfair, so it's very easy to miss. In general they announce very little audibly about the actual game, it's a very different experience from watching on TV.


The first time I saw baseball from box seats after 30 years of upper deck, it was two different games. While you couldn’t hear, seeing the players speak to one another was a blast.


I'm surprised that with this many comments about the relationship between testing, development, and QA there is so little mention of environment and deploy process.

The usability of your test environment (and associated tooling) has a massive impact on quality assurance.

Every small difference between Production and Production-Plus-Feature creates friction and, even in systems of only moderate complexity, that friction adds up fast.


LLMs will use Wikipedia the same way humans use it


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: