If you remember Geometry, there are two ways to prove something:
- By making it (constructing)
- By contradiction (reductio ad absurdum)
During the late 1800s to early 1900s, when math was becoming more formalized, a group of mathematicians had issues with the second method.
From their point of view if you can’t show how to make it, then you’ve not proven that it exists.
Now it turns out that indirect proofs like contradiction requires the law of excluded middle: If something isn’t true, then it must be false (or vice versa).
It turns out that AoC is needed/implied, for the law of excluded middle; hence the objection to AoC; and enables these non-constructive proofs.
Fun fact: the creators of V wanted to make a version of the classic novel warning about Fascism coming to America, "It Can't Happen Here" by Sinclair Lewis, but it was deemed too cerebral for American audiences by networks.
So they swapped the fascists for aliens in disguise.
Nice. This is the first I’ve heard-of or read about Huey Long: "When he was gone it seemed that a beneficent peace had fallen on the land. Father Coughlin, Reno, Townsend, et al., were after all pygmies compared with Huey. He had been a major phenomenon."
The demagogue party has flipped, but of course we’re living with the consequences all the same.
Does it matter? A success rate of 0.007% is practically a statistical error. It signifies that the method is not feasible regardless of individual factors.
Yes. But not if you set up a timer to do it automatically. (As long as you set up the timer before shabat obviously)
There is also apparently a slightly more technologically minded sub-sect of Judaism which considers only electricity generators that actually burn things (coal, oil, gas, biomass, etc) to be "fire". Battery powered devices are therefore OK, as would be things purely powered by solar power (as the sun is technically not "on fire") nucear power or even hydroelectric power. For the vast majority of electricity grids though, at least a percentage of generation will be from fueled generators and so forbidden on shabat.
This is a technical “solution” which ignores a market and legal problem: There’s no incentive to keep things secure, because the accountability falls on the rank-and-file, but rarely if ever on the actual leaders that all but require insecure incentives.
We have Boeing-level incidents daily, except that it can be swept under.
reply