Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | deknos's commentslogin

> What will we end up with? Only attested modems / endpoints in the home?

you might laugh/cry, but there was a time in germany, when the telephone at home was owned by the state (the "Post") and you were NOT allowed to tinker with it.

personally, i guess, things like sneakernet, lorawan and hamradio will become a lot more popular over time.


Same for the US- until the feds broke up Bell between 1974 and 82. but, there were no technical hurdles. Anybody have a toy whistle?

My understanding is that the phone company owned the phone, not the state.

In many countries the state owned the phone company.

If there is only 1 telephone company, either owned by the state, directly or indirectly, or even just a monopoly... what is the difference?


And who gets to tell the phone company how to operate?

We try and segment it into governments and corporations. But really there is no real differences between the two. They are all governing policies for groups of people arranged in a sort of heirical pattern. The big top level group, the one that managed to gain control of physical territory is the nation-state or perhaps more accurately the Government(capital G) of which. allocating control to various lesser groups. Including physical sub territories and for profit enterprises (The incorporation).

The point being, even in the most rampant capitalist[1](an economic policy favoring freedom of operation in it's sub groups) nation the for profit enterprises are licensed and regulated and if needed(see world war 2) controlled by the state.

1. As opposed to communism, an economic policy favoring fairness of operation in it's sub groups. Or fascism, an economic policy where no one knows what it is but every one agrees is bad. fascism really is hard to pin down, used as the default bogey man by everybody, but original Italian theory suggests it favors having the most successful sub groups run the state, which would be in the capitalist corner. however the largest wielders of the theory(1930's Germany) used it as a social fairness issue, which is in the communism domain.


Doesn’t ham radio not allow transmissions to be encrypted by law? That rules out most of the internet.

That is true. They can be authenticated, though. I don't think it should be read as ham radio specifically, but (illegal, pirate) amateur use of radio more generally.

Same in NL... we used to rent our telephones from the "PTT".

My pet theory is that network protocols will evolve to require some kind of certificate-based signing to uniquely identify individuals and groups. Hardware and operating systems will have legal mandates to enforce this. Penalties for carrying unsigned traffic will be stiff.

The “upsides” will be plentiful! User verification schemes will be streamlined like never before. If you think there are downsides… well, just think of the kids, damn it!


You probably pay for tests and that the company has to be audited for medical diagnostics standards

so.. where can i get this data? XD


> Couldn't NSA have not known about an issue with ML-KEM, and thus wanted to prevent its commercial acceptance, which it did simply by approving the algorithm?

Could, but they did not do that. So, the question is to be stated: Why?


I think you may have missed my point.


i would not use html(5). XHTML? perhaps. but try to find 3 parsers, which parse html in the same way and not segfaulting.

It's not possible. HTML is worse. You need at least something, which on parsing does not segfault.


i never understood why the markdown mime type was not used in emailclients in webclients or desktop programs...

that would eliminate most html usage and enable longer texts than 70-85 characters per line.


It’s up to the e-mail client implementors, but I would personally prefer text/enriched, RFC 1896, instead of markdown.


I cannot wait until it's in an appstore for android and that it will work with android/iphone together. And i seriously hope you do not abandon it. That being said, i have questions:

1. When i have a higher version, but others have a lowerpaid version, can i still connect to more members, or am i constrained by the lowestpaying customer in the network? 2. Do you have reproducible builds? 3. airdrop sadly only works with iphones, how will this be done with android? 4. would it be a possibility, that after some time you made decent money, you consider a even higher paid stage, where i can fully build the best /most feature version myself? just in case you ever leave the project? 5. https://github.com/RedGridMGRS/RedGridMGRS is a 404 for me? 6. Would it be possible you also use openstreetmap or better to say integrate map loading from there? 7. Would you consider adding something like https://www.fixphrase.com / what3words-alternative into the app, so coordinates could be uses with phrases?


Thanks you! Just started working on this project based on systems I use, and have gripes with, in the military. No plans to abandon it, but I understand your concern. This is the project I actually want to use myself so it's going to keep getting built.

1.Your tier determines your own device limit. If you have Pro+Link (8 devices), you can host a session with 8 people. The people joining don't need Pro+Link, they just need the free version with Field Link support (which covers 2 devices). So the session creator's tier sets the ceiling, not the lowest paying member. 2.Not yet, but it's open source so you can build from source and verify. Reproducible builds are something I'd like to get to but haven't prioritized over features yet. Fair ask though. 3.Good catch. AirDrop is just one option in the iOS share sheet for AAR exports. On Android it'll use the native share intent, so whatever sharing apps you have installed (email, Drive, Nearby Share, etc). The session export is just a JSON file so it works over any transfer method. I have put off building out the Android version for now because as a solo dev I need 12 testers before I can submit to the Play Store. If you are interested, or know anyone that is, please reach out! Would love to get testers for the Android version going! 4.That's an interesting idea. Something like a "source license" tier where you get build access and can self-host updates if the project goes dark. I'll think about that. The MIT + Commons Clause license already lets you build from source for personal use, but a paid tier with commercial self-build rights could make sense for teams that need that guarantee. 5.Good catch, the correct link is https://github.com/RedGridTactical/RedGridMGRS. Must be a typo somewhere, I'll fix it. 6.Yes, OpenStreetMap is actually what the offline maps use under the hood already. The tile sources are OpenTopoMap (which is built on OSM data) and USGS Topo. Adding more tile sources including vanilla OSM is on the list! 7.I hadn't seen fixphrase before, that's interesting. what3words has licensing issues that make it hard to integrate into open source projects, but an open alternative like that could work. I'll look into it. The main concern would be making sure it works fully offline since the whole point is no network dependency.

I appreciate all the feedback!


i would pay if it is in a format, which is not also trying to deceive me like bluray with its fucking DRM in its player.


would be nice, if there's a modifier in there, which says showinwebui=(true|false) :D


you know artipie? it is only in java, but does a similar part.

will your stuff be really opensource?


https://github.com/artifact-keeper

There are 7 or 8 repositories now in this org. Feel free to take, use, or help imrove the code. MIT Open Source.


thanks. another question:

Would it be possible, that the storage of pypi/whatever is some s3 bucket, where you have it encrypted (with authentication), and when you deliver it to a client, you get it, decrypt it, test for authentication and deliver it to the client? the encryption is something that artipie is lacking sadly.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: