Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | beacon294's commentslogin

Well that is already how it is done with numerous multi-decade open rewrites of closed games. They usually require the asset pack.

I don't know how this squares with law, but Oracle v Google gave a very valuable judgment to the public that an API is not copywritable. If we take the LLM out of it, that's all we are talking about in the pure case.

Of course, we can't take the LLM out, but it is the starting point.


> Well that is already how it is done with numerous multi-decade open rewrites of closed games

Serious such rewrites don't start with the code of the closed game!

> I don't know how this squares with law, but Oracle v Google gave a very valuable judgment to the public that an API is not copywritable. If we take the LLM out of it, that's all we are talking about in the pure case.

Not at all. The LLM used to write grit has seen the git code. That is what we're talking about here.

> Of course, we can't take the LLM out, but it is the starting point.

The LLM isn't the important thing. The important thing is that the git source code was used to make grit.


>Serious such rewrites don't start with the code of the closed game!

No, but they often involve reverse engineering the binary pretty heavily.


> No, but they often involve reverse engineering the binary pretty heavily.

… and those often end up in legally dubious situations.


Just buy 95% creatine monohydrate. This is the most common formulation, but others do exist.


Creatine is $10 at Walmart, I don't think they are paying for astroturfing. It's a chemical like salt.


ZDR is also on by default and deepseek is not ZDR.


I have a similar experience, however if you spent $5 at these rates you may have an issue with caching in your client.


I agree with this sentiment but the reasoned anecdotes do not agree. I imagine the flagship models have modalities/usages that we hn-ers don't imagine easily.


Have you read the MAKER/MDAP paper? 1 million sequential tasks.


No, I haven't - hadn't heard of it. I'll try to squeeze in a quick read in the coming weeks!


As you practice it will be apparent, you simply keep working on the application architecture yourself.


Do you have this on a shareable place / forge? I have a farm animal spelling game and want to extend my library and build more ideas.


To be fair, you're cherry picking traffic fatality data. It's topical now but it's not common.


I actually don’t think there’s a single year where San Francisco has seen zero pre-teen traffic deaths. I think even my neighborhood is positive for the last two years. Taipei has more people, more children, and even by a percentage.

The number of pre-teen traffic fatalities is the only concern I have when I’m thinking of letting my children walk around because I think the other risks are relatively overblown. Sure we have an occasional Bill Gene Hobbs and the like but I think only traffic fatalities are near certainty.

These are for accompanied children, so leaving a 5 year old to wander is way different than when I was 5 years old. In SF, I’d rate the chance of survival to 12 at under 90% for unaccompanied 5 year olds walking around the city along the range that I used to at that time.

Teens are pretty self-capable in decision making but pre-teens just don’t have judgment yet. I feel like this is a pretty reasonable statistic to match.


There's no need to cherry pick data. The US's traffic fatality record is bad pretty much over the entire country.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: