Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more _exec's commentslogin

I'm curious as well. Why not?


'pbsd gave a much better answer than I could have.


Stock-pics aside, I think the content is mildly-interesting and a good starting point.


Agree, I like the article. It would be a pity if the stock0-pics put people off.


Does anybody have any (other and more thorough) resources for 'learning how to learn'? Perhaps book suggestions? One of my goals is to become an autodictact / polymath and I'm seeking way to make the process of acquiring new data / skills / learning more time-efficient and more organized (and systematic).

Are there any kind of 'learning theories/strategies' out there? I'm not seeking resources per se (I know about Khan academy, MIT OCW, 'bookportals' on Tor etc), but rather some sort of systematic method similar to the one described in the link but perhaps more detailed and (maybe) anecdote-/experience-based.


The Pragmatic Programmers have a book on learning called "Pragmatic Thinking and Learning". I own it and would highly recommend it, one of the more underrated books. It covers the Dreyfus learning model which was mentioned in the article.

The examples and language tend to be programming related (for example one chapter is titled "Debugging your Brain" iirc) because that's the intended audience but I'd also recomend it for non-programmers.

Very good blend of theory (Dreyfus model, r-/l-mode) and practical advice on how to improve your learning and generally use your brain better.

http://pragprog.com/book/ahptl/pragmatic-thinking-and-learni...


I actually do own a copy, thank you for reminding me to read it again. Very useful strategies and the type of 'metaphors' used in the book (CS/IT-related) made it easy to understand.


Learn epistemology (the philosophy of learning).

Most stuff in the field is bad (worse than useless). Start with this book:

http://beginningofinfinity.com/

Karl Popper's books are good too.

Epistemology is the long term route. No instant results, but useful for everything and very efficient in the long run. That's the best way if you plan to learn about many things to be a polymath.

And for discussion of autodidact stuff, ask your questions on this email list:

https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/taking-ch...

I've already done this stuff. Feel free to email me curi@curi.us


Epistemology is rather about what "knowing" means. It's not a set of rules that tell you how to learn a language etc.


Epistemology explains how learning (aka creating knowledge) happens and what sorts of methods are capable of learning or not, and what sort are more or less effective at learning (aka at getting knowledge). This is useful to actually learning (anything) effectively.

Note again that most work in the field is terrible, so it doesn't actually do this. But the stuff I recommended does.


Epistemology is a field of philosophy not psychology.


To increase what you get from books you read, maybe this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Read_a_Book


Interesting. I like the list of classics at the end, though I'm not sure if it's outdated (then again, it's a list of _classics_).


Josh Waitzkin (of chess movie fame) wrote this one:

http://www.amazon.com/The-Art-Learning-Journey-Performance/d...


That's a fantastic book!


Great question! Self-directed learning is the way of the future. I'm a big fan of Trello for breaking learning goals down into manageable blocks - create a board of your overall goal, then create a list of specific learning outcomes you can tick off as you go (kind of a mash-up of Steven Covey's 'begin with the end in mind' and SMART goals - specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, timed). In my experience the foible of learning is distraction, so staying accountable to Trello keeps you on track. Perhaps it would also help to commit to teach someone else, to cement what you've learnt and to stay accountable to your goals; does anyone know of peer-to-peer learning networks like this?


I use Trello for my learning as well. I have a board called "Self Investment" that roughly corresponds to a mixture of SMART goals and other concepts. It's one of my two long term boards, the other being "Ideas".

Whatever tool you use it's a pretty good idea to keep your long term learning goals stored somewhere and get them out of your head (fairly standard idea in time-/selfmanagement)

Edit: I actually have a third "long term" board called "Books etc." where I store the titles of books that look interesting, interesting youtube videos, elearning courses etc. I'd kind of like to integrate that with the "Self Investment" board but haven't found a good way yet...open to suggestions.


I've had some pretty good results with Scott Young's ebook and blog in general: http://www.scotthyoung.com (ebook is on the side of the page, can't find a direct link to it).


My goal is to achieve the same goal, except with n-number of subjects (math, science, humanities, the arts, etc) over x-number of years. Thanks for the suggestion!


Have you watched many of Rich Hickey's talks? There are videos of them around.. I think you would like them.


Any particular video(s)? All I found was 'Simple Made Easy' and some other Clojure / Datomic related videos. Am I missing anything?


All of Rich Hickey's talks great, but they're not really about learning how to learn. "Hammock Driven Development" is probably the closest, and is about approaching problem solving generally.

Both "Simple made easy" and "Are we there yet" are pretty general, not necessarily Clojure-specific talks, although they do point to Clojure and more broadly FP as a possible solution to the problems presented.

http://blip.tv/clojure/hammock-driven-development-4475586

http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy

http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Are-We-There-Yet-Rich-Hic...


Perfect, just what the doctor ordered. May I suggest you create a forum / subreddit for the readers to discuss the book?


Good idea, I created a subreddit: http://www.reddit.com/r/mfgan/


Perfect. I'd add a link to the list of resources :)

Thank you for the awesome work! I'll try and leave feedback on the subreddit once I get started.


> Perfect. I'd add a link to the list of resources :)

done. :)


I suppose, but I think this comic is more related to how 'mash up' businesses are popping up on the Internet everyday.

Example: Zynga depending on Facebook who depends on Akamai who depends on L3. There are a lot of layers involved.


Quick note: why not integrate with the major mail providers to get my address book from there instead of making me enter them one by one? You had me on board until that screen showed up..


We are working on that for web (which is in beta), I'm assuming that's what you are mentioning. Our backend is ready to do Google Contacts and Yahoo, but haven't had time to wire up the front-end. If you download our app for Android or iPhone, you can use the address book there and create Magic Circles.


What's the difference between the two versions?


one has all the academic fluff, not the other.


I like your work. How complete is it (%) ?


Thanks! I'd say ~70. Won't grow in length, but needs tweaking in a bunch of places.


Are you open to suggestions / additions by the way?


I'd love to - that's why I posted it here!

(you can use the email address on the main guide page if it's more convenient)


If I may ask, what was the name of your company / product? Is it still alive? I must say I'm highly intrigued by the idea of carrier-grade BitTorrent.


It's on ice. Not alive, not dead either. I'm chasing another opportunity now, but keep this one still in mind. I guess my email should be visible in the profile, feel free to contact me.


Definitely interested.


I wish they'd have provided a download-only option, but I suppose unlimited online streaming sorta makes up for it.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: