Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | 3836293648's commentslogin

There's still bitrot on the X.org side even if your DM is maintained

Only on systemd/logind systems. Bitrot doesn't just happen, it caused by your dependencies considering your usecases obsolete.

Oh, so only on systems running the standard stack that 90% of Linux systems run then. Nope, no bitrot here.

Always the same lies...


I see no contradiction? Bitrot is caused by some other project moving. Of course the niche projects will suffer less from it if they incorporate less innovations.

Edit: You really do like calling other people liars and fascists?


We have a liar problem, and it turns out a fascist problem, when it comes to the X vs. Wayland kerfuffle, which shouldn't even be a thing.

Your level of antagonism is unwarranted.

> All of the X11 based WMs are slowly bit-rotting.

was the statement I was replying to. In 10 years of using dwm I've not been aware of any bitrot that affects me. Certainly nome in the WM itself.


There's X11libre for Linux and there's X on OpenBSD and FreeBSD. I am sure it will be fine.

Define what problems you think exist please.

How is Asahi not native?

The drivers, while impressively reverse-engineered, are basically alpha-quality by Linux standards. Even well-studied M1 machines will have spotty support in comparison to what an OEM can provide officially.

Those that are implemented have been very reliable in my experience, I think that labeling them “alpha-quality by Linux standards” is a ridiculous claim

Then you need an Intel or AMD laptop as a frame of reference. M1 is implemented as-is with much of the silicon's onboard accelerators entirely dark. Hardware accelerated video encode/decode is a lost cause, Thunderbolt will likely never happen, NEON is your fastest SIMD accelerator and cpuidle is still not really figured out.

Those are all perfectly acceptable limitations for a POC. And the GPU drivers are particularly well-made. But it doesn't really come close to how seriously AMD and Intel take Linux.


There's a big difference between saying that many of the drivers are missing entirely, and saying that the drivers that exist are alpha-quality.

+1. Been running Asahi Linux for half a year now. Everything that's advertized as working is working great.

my dude no. https://asahilinux.org/docs/platform/feature-support/m1/#tab...

even in the m1 there are 4 WIP in the support table, 2 TBA and 10 non mainline boxes for the M1 pro


> Those that are implemented

Asahi is also still a platform with a huge pile of out of tree patches on top because the platform itself is pretty unusual, requiring for example, a 16K page size kernel which is unlike pretty much every other arm Linux platform.

Presumably OP meant a Linux distro using a normal upstream kernel?

Vulkan also runs on Apple Silicon without translation on linux


It actually requires translation everywhere. GPUs have their own internal API that Vulkan, OpenGL, DirectX, etc. translate into. That is what drivers do.


That's being disingenuous. Of course a high level api has to be implemented in terms of hardware specifics, but you're implying, hopefully unintentionally, that that hardware interface is Metal, and it's not.

You can run Vulkan on Apple Silicon as natively as you can run Metal, even if some parts of it don't map too nicely to the hardware.

We only seriously say translate when we go from one high level API to another, just like we call some compilers transpilers even though literally everything is a compiler for something.


Because that's the difference between the paid and free versions


But that goes in the chain of thought, not the response


Unironically this though. Computers are bad for children, if they want to use them, make then actually learn what they're getting into.

Or even better, don't let them have any kind of computer at all. Unfortunately that only works if your entire community goes down that route


But the redesign was targeted at stores, not end consumers


Do you really thinks stores would not be smart enough to realize that it was a game console? I don't think it would trick stores.


That's not the claim being made and you know it


Yes it does, it was a greek colony off the southern coast of Italy, which were the primary greek connection to the romans which how the name stuck.


Much like the many names for Germany.


Except for the transcripts where they chose the name because they thought it was funny to offend the English


Then spell the letters if the name offends you


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: