Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

No, AI is not yet able to architect. The confusion here is the inability to discern architecture from planning.

Planning is the ability to map concerns to solutions and project solution delivery according to resources available. I am not convinced AI is anywhere near getting that right. It’s not straightforward even when your human assets are commodities.

Acting on plans is called task execution.

Architecture is the design and art of interrelated systems. This involves layers of competing and/or cooperative plans. AI absolutely cannot do this. A gross hallucination at one layer potentially destroys or displaces other layers and that is catastrophically expensive. That is why real people do this work and why they are constantly audited.



It can’t actively become a coding agent and make the changes, but it doesn’t do that for individual scripts now, and yet we say it can code.

And yet I can ask it how to architect my database in a logical way, and it clearly has solid ideas that again, it doesn’t script itself.

So really it teaches us or instructs us one way to do things, it’s not executing in any realm…yet


None of my parent comment had anything to do with writing code. Architects in physical engineering don’t hammer nails or pour concrete. Architects in software, likewise, aren’t concerned with islands of code.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: